Fiduciary Liability

Fiduciary Liability Insurance vs. the ERISA Fidelity Bond: Why a Bond Is Not Enough

An ERISA fidelity bond is not fiduciary liability insurance, and having one does not protect you if a participant sues over how the plan was run. The bond protects the plan itself against losses from dishonesty, such as an employee stealing contributions. Fiduciary liability insurance protects the people and the company responsible for the plan when they are accused of breaching their duties, which is a far more common and expensive problem.

The confusion is understandable. Federal law generally requires plans to carry a fidelity bond, so most sponsors buy one, see the word "fiduciary" in the paperwork, and assume the box is checked. Fiduciary liability insurance, by contrast, is optional, and many private companies and nonprofits that sponsor a 401(k) or health plan have never been offered it.

What the fidelity bond actually covers

The ERISA fidelity bond is a form of crime coverage. It reimburses the plan when someone who handles plan funds or property steals them or otherwise causes a loss through fraud or dishonesty. Think of a bookkeeper who diverts employee deferrals, or a trustee who forges a distribution request.

The bond's beneficiary is the plan, not the sponsor and not the individuals who run it. It does not pay a defense attorney, it does not respond to a lawsuit alleging poor investment choices, and it does not cover an honest mistake in plan administration. Federal rules set the required bond amount by a formula tied to plan assets, so confirm your figure with your plan advisor or the Department of Labor. Because the bond is legally required, nearly every plan has one, which is exactly why it is so often mistaken for broader protection.

What fiduciary liability insurance covers

Fiduciary liability insurance responds to claims that a fiduciary breached a duty owed to the plan or its participants. Common allegations include paying excessive recordkeeping or investment fees, keeping imprudent or underperforming investment options on the menu, failing to monitor service providers, giving participants inaccurate information, or making administrative errors in enrollment, eligibility or distributions.

The policy typically pays defense costs, settlements and judgments on behalf of the plan sponsor, the plan itself, and the individuals serving as trustees, committee members or administrators. Defense costs alone can be substantial because these cases involve expert witnesses and detailed financial analysis, and many policies pay defense inside the limit, so a long case erodes what remains for settlement.

Many policies also include coverage for voluntary compliance programs. When a sponsor discovers an operational error and corrects it through a government correction program, the policy may reimburse certain fees and costs, subject to a sublimit. Some policies also provide a modest amount for certain civil penalties, again subject to sublimits and exclusions. Terms vary, so read this section closely.

Who is a fiduciary

Fiduciary status under ERISA is functional. You are a fiduciary if you exercise discretion over plan management or plan assets, or have discretionary authority over plan administration, regardless of your title. The owner who signs the recordkeeping contract, the CFO on the investment committee, the HR director who decides eligibility questions, and the board that appoints all of them may each be fiduciaries.

Fiduciaries can be held personally liable for losses caused by a breach, and in some cases for the breaches of co-fiduciaries they knew about and failed to address. Corporate indemnification may help, but it is only as strong as the company's balance sheet and may be limited by law or by the plan documents. Fiduciary liability insurance typically backs up that indemnification with outside dollars.

Settlor functions versus fiduciary functions

Not every plan decision is a fiduciary act. Decisions about whether to offer a plan, what benefits it provides, how much to contribute, and whether to amend or terminate it are generally considered settlor functions. They are business decisions made on behalf of the company, and ERISA's fiduciary standards do not apply to them.

Once the plan exists, however, the work of running it is fiduciary in nature. Selecting investments, choosing a recordkeeper, negotiating fees, communicating with participants and processing claims all carry fiduciary duties. The line matters for coverage because fiduciary liability policies are built around fiduciary acts; a dispute over a settlor decision may instead belong under directors and officers coverage or may not be insured at all.

Health and welfare plans deserve attention too. Sponsors of self-funded health plans make fiduciary decisions about claims administration, pharmacy benefit contracts and fee arrangements, and claims activity in this area has been growing. A fiduciary liability policy should typically name the health plan as well as the retirement plan.

What to ask when buying

Ask whether the definition of an insured includes the plan, the sponsor, and every individual who serves as a trustee, committee member or administrator, including former and future ones. Ask which plans are scheduled and whether newly created or acquired plans are automatically covered. Ask whether defense costs are inside or outside the limit.

Ask how the policy handles excessive-fee allegations and whether there is any sublimit for them. Ask about voluntary compliance coverage, the size of its sublimit, and whether it applies to both retirement and health plans. Ask about the retention, whether the policy is claims-made, and how long the extended reporting period runs if the plan terminates or the company is sold.

Talk with an independent agent

If your only protection for your retirement or health plan is the fidelity bond, the people running that plan are carrying personal exposure they may not realize they have. An independent agent at Provident Financial Group can explain how fiduciary liability coverage fits alongside your bond and your D&O policy, then quote multiple carriers so you can compare terms. Call (866) 964-6660 or request a quote online.

Frequently asked questions

If we have the required ERISA bond, are our committee members personally protected? No. The bond protects the plan against theft and dishonesty; it does not defend or indemnify committee members accused of breaching their duties. Personal protection for those individuals typically comes from fiduciary liability insurance combined with corporate indemnification.

Does our D&O policy already cover fiduciary claims? Most D&O policies specifically exclude claims arising under ERISA, so they generally will not respond to fiduciary breach allegations. Some package policies for small businesses include a limited fiduciary component, but the limits and terms are often narrower than a standalone policy. Ask your agent to review the exclusions.

We outsource everything to a recordkeeper and advisor. Do we still need fiduciary liability coverage? Generally, yes. Outsourcing shifts some tasks but not the duty to prudently select and monitor the providers you hire. If a participant alleges the fees were excessive or the investment menu was imprudent, the sponsor and its committee are typically named regardless of who performed the day-to-day work.

Want this reviewed for your business?

Submit once and we'll bring back up to 10 carrier quotes, with the coverage differences explained in plain English. No obligation.

Get Up to 10 Quotes

General information only. Coverage is governed by the terms of the policy actually issued. This article is not legal advice.